As the 2008 slams the brakes on, editors the breadth of the land put their feet up on the desk and just serve you some reconstituted yesterdays: top-10-20-30-50-100 countdowns of stuff that happened over the past twelve months. But as you grind your way through one end of year music supplement banging on about Kings Of Leon & MGMT after another, your eyes go oblong and there’s a sense of intense, giddying deja vu. Haven’t we seen it all before? In every other magazine/paper/webzine/cereal box? Like, every year? Forever?
Slice through the crap: this is The Only Top 35 Albums Of The Year Countdown You’ll Ever Need.
Number 35: Bonkers novelty rap collective. Shows staff have sense of humour.
Number 34: Reserved for Britpop ’survivors’ who’ve made ‘their best album in years’.
Number 33: Wacky side-project of big-name band singer, which is a wacky electro-pop concept album about magic animals.
Number 32: Something from Iceland.
Number 31: The name that keeps turning up on every electro/house compilation CD released that year. eg. Simian Mobile Disco in 07.
Number 30: Real authentic alt.country dude who made the album in a cave in the Appalachians/once dated Joanna Newsom.
Number 29: Return of once-derided old-timer who used to symboise naffness, but has subverted expectations by making an album of honest, brooding ballads with a hip young producer.
Number 28: This space is reserved for Bruce Springsteen if he makes an album in the year of the list. If not, The Gaslight Anthem or Hold Steady should sub-in.
Number 27: Nick Cave.
Number 26: Disappointing third album from previously much-touted act, so bad editorial embarrassment means its been crowbarred in here as a Pravda-style exercise in shrinking them slowly rather than dropping them like a hot brick as would be most appropriate.
Number 25: The band that everyone was tipping as the year’s biggest act in January.
Number 24: You’ve never even heard of this one. You never will. Even as your read the blurb, you find your mind simultaneously erasing the entry.
Number 23: Glitchy & worthy & difficult record you’ve listened to once. Squarepusher, basically.
Number 21: British Sea Power.
Number 20: Token world muso.
Number 19: The band who’ve got a reputation for being ‘influential’, and have a geographically specific ’scene’ organised around them that they put on semi-mythical ‘parties’ for at a semi-mythical ‘venue’. eg: No Age & The Smell, Chairlift & Concert Hall Of Williamsburg.
Number 18: Band who wrote album of songs inspired by the tragic accidental/drug death of their bass player last year. Somewhere, the blurb says ‘courageous’.
Number 17: Laura Marling.
Number 16: Cheesy pop band masquerading as ‘wonky-pop’/'nu-pop’/'underground pop’, which only barely disguises the fact that they’re Roxette with alt. dress sense.
Number 16: Put in a ’stunning’ performance on Jools Holland.
Number 15: DJ who made “the year’s party-starting mash-up compilation” that you’ve never actually heard at a party that wasn’t put on by media-insiders. And never made any of those partygoers do more than pout extra aggressively.
Number 14: Elbow.
Number 13: Hyper-obscure album everyone was bamboozled into voting for cos Pitchfork gave it a 9.9, despite sounding like every other folk album ever.
Number 12: Rapper facing child sex charges.
Number 11: Dizzee/Bizzle (pop grime slot shared on a rotational basis)
Number 10: Album described as a ‘groundbreaking fusion of dance and rock’.
Number 9: Tape of Bob Dylan coughing up some phlegm in June 1972, found in someone’s attic, dusted off, reissued, and hagiographised in the Sunday papers as a heartbreaking work of staggering genius.
Numbers 8 – 2: Records that were OK: no one was mad about them, but no one disliked them much either, so they swum through the middle course, whereas intense records that some people were truly passionate about but others really hated all ultimately failed to make the cut.
Number 1: Coldplay (Q), Arctic Monkeys (NME), Sven Vath (Mixmag), Neil Young (Uncut), Neil Young (Mojo), Neil Young (Classic Rock), Neil Young (Home & Garden), people humming transcendentally over distorted tape loops of concrete being laid (The Wire).
GAVIN HAYNES












Reader Comments
November 28th, 2008
Article. Couldn’t agree more.
November 28th, 2008
can’t wait to kill myself over the tortured words of some poor music hack having to explain why ‘this sex is on fire’ is seminal.
November 28th, 2008
A bit boring but Glasvegas and Vampire Weekend made two of the best albums of the year. MGMT made 2 of the best songs.
November 28th, 2008
there’s no such thing as ‘best song’ simon
November 28th, 2008
i would like to date joanna newsom… great arse.
November 28th, 2008
These fucking lists and the music “blogosphere” (gag) are so atrocious. It’s almost enough to make me give up completely on trying to follow new music. MGMT? Vampire Weekend? Is anyone even trying anymore?
(#27 I can get behind, though. At least we still have our yearly semi-awesome Nick Cave album to look forward to.)
November 28th, 2008
no 31 boys noize
no.26 i suppose reads like bloc party to me
so on so forth
great list indeed hahaha
November 30th, 2008
Is this supposed to be funny? Because it certainly isn’t. It’s more sad and pathetic.
BTW, this entry is insulting, not funny: “Number 20: Token world muso.” If you think “World Music” is necessary then you know nothing about “World Music.” To most of us outside of your comfortable and cushy First World societies, World Music is just fucking music like all of that crap from Bruce Springsteen and Cristina Aguilera. There’s no difference where the music is from. If it’s crap, it’s crap; I don;t care if it’s from Singapore or Bristol, UK. Fuck Best of lists; they are for morons and a sorry excuse for a wage.
November 30th, 2008
“Fuck Best of lists; they are for morons and a sorry excuse for a wage.”
er djelrock? are you a fucking moron?
December 1st, 2008
djelrock - I don’t think you get the point of this list. By the way… don’t feel bad, your world album will make a list one day :)
December 1st, 2008
djelrock - I don’t think you get the point of this list. By the way… don’t feel bad, your world album will make a list one day :)
December 1st, 2008
djelrock - I don’t think you get the point of this list. By the way… don’t feel bad, your world album will make a list one day :)
December 1st, 2008
Brilliant list! My favorite entry - Number 13: Hyper-obscure album everyone was bamboozled into voting for cos Pitchfork gave it a 9.9, despite sounding like every other folk album ever.
I immediately thought of the Vashti Bunyan album of a couple years ago which was pleasant enough, but nothing special.
December 1st, 2008
I would love to be as jaded and blasé as this about new music every year. It would be oh so very much easier than paying attention or giving a shit, wouldn’t it.
Rather.
December 2nd, 2008
What is this “list” exactly? You figure out the riddle which then gives you the band name for each number? Judging by most of this tripe, I would suspect that this “list” is propagated with nothing but shite indie bands, which are nothing more than mopey dopes making mopey music for their dopey friends. It’s all the same - vanilla-milquetoast crap that has no business being released out of the myriad basements it’s made in.
As far as I’m concerned, to make the world a better place, punch an indie band member in the face. Repeatedly.
December 2nd, 2008
Is this piece really that confusing or did everybody on the internet just fail basic reading comprehension?
The point is not that new music is lame or that world music is unlistenable garbage bankrolled by Western guilt issues (debatable), it’s that “music journalists” are some of the most gormless, formulaic writers on earth and that their year-end lists follow an astonishingly specific pattern from year to year.
December 3rd, 2008
THANK YOU Ames!
After reading nearly all these posts, i was thinking the exact same thing. The whole list is a jab at ‘journalists’ and it seems as though nearly everyone is taking it as a serious post.
Settle down.
December 3rd, 2008
The list is brilliant. Especially if you can solve the riddles and figure out which hip new indie band the writer is talking about. Jesus, some people are stupid. Thank you for explaining it ames, so I don’t have to.
December 3rd, 2008
capper is a slapper I love you andy love chicago.
December 12th, 2008
I don’t get it what are the bands plz i am not understanding this list plz help if this is humor then you suck
December 17th, 2008
list..listing?? i thought this was a ‘fisting’ site - click